
COP17 biodiversity credits: what the additionality study means

COP17 did not ban or approve biodiversity credits. The COP17 biodiversity credits outcome from Yerevan was mixed: credits and offsets stay on the list of ways to finance the global nature targets, but governments also asked for a study on whether they generate additionality, meaning whether they pay for nature gains that would not have happened anyway. That question can only be settled with field data, starting from a dated baseline and ending with records a verifier can trace. This post sets out what was decided, what the EU launched alongside it, and where community-led biodiversity monitoring fits.
COP17 biodiversity credits: what was decided
The UN Biodiversity Conference closed in Yerevan, Armenia, on Saturday 31 October 2026. UN News reports that parties adopted nearly 50 decisions and a "Yerevan Pathway" setting priorities for the four years left to deliver the 23 targets of the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework. Nearly $2 billion of new funding was announced, though the same report notes that a global review found the world off track on its biodiversity targets.
On credits, the starting point is target 19, the finance target. Carbon Brief notes that offsets and credits are "officially accepted as one of the official means of achieving the GBF's target 19". COP17 did not change that. It did add a question mark.
During the closing plenary, Peru asked for offsets to be scrutinised as a finance tool. "For us, there is no additionality there at all," its delegate said, according to Carbon Brief. Carbon Brief reports that Peru's call for a study made it into the final resource mobilisation decision. The wording below comes from the draft text of that decision, CBD/COP/17/L.29 of 30 October 2026, which asks for "a study to evaluate the conceptual and practical relevance of biodiversity credits and offsets as a financial biodiversity-related expenditure, considering whether biodiversity credits and offsets generate additionality in biodiversity conservation". Carbon Brief notes that the study is subject to available financial resources.

The wider mood was divided. Before the conference, the UN's biodiversity chief, Astrid Schomaker, told Carbon Brief that credits "remain an important instrument" if they can be "high-integrity". At a COP17 press conference, Indigenous leaders rejected the use of "charismatic species" such as lions and rhinos as credits to offset biodiversity loss, Carbon Brief reports. Both sides are asking the same underlying question: what does a credit actually represent on the ground?
The EU's Friends of Credits for Nature and Biodiversity
Earlier in the conference, the EU pushed in the other direction. On Tuesday 27 October, Environment Commissioner Jessika Roswall launched the Friends of Credits for Nature and Biodiversity at an event the EU co-hosted with France and Peru. The European Commission describes it as an "informal, inclusive, government-led initiative" to build international support for nature credits and strengthen cooperation on biodiversity finance.
The Commission says Finland, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Portugal and Spain, as well as Australia, Botswana, Canada, Chile, Indonesia, Japan and New Zealand, "were welcomed to the initiative". Other countries attended the event and expressed interest in joining, and relevant international organisations are welcome.
The group builds on the EU's Roadmap towards Nature Credits, adopted in July 2025, which the Commission says "sets out how to develop and test reliable nature credits" through research and pilot projects, with consultation and practical testing along the way. Next steps named by the Commission are an EU side-event at the UN climate conference, COP31, on 18 November, and "a formal endorsement of a Joint Statement among government members".
Peru co-hosting a pro-credit event and then asking whether offsets add anything is less contradictory than it looks. Governments that want a credit market also want it to be believable, and believability comes down to evidence.
Disclosure moved too: TNFD and the ISSB draft
Demand for nature data does not only come from credit buyers. In October 2026, ahead of COP17, the TNFD published updates to its recommendations, the first since they were released in September 2023, along with version 2.0 of its LEAP assessment approach.
Also in October 2026, the ISSB published an Exposure Draft of IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Practice Statement 1, Nature-related Disclosures, which draws on the TNFD's work. Comments are open until 19 February 2027.
For project developers this matters indirectly. Companies that report on nature will ask the projects they fund for site-level evidence, and the same questions about baselines and change over time will come up whether the money is a credit purchase or a disclosed nature investment.
Why additionality is a monitoring question
Additionality is easy to define and hard to prove. A project has to show that biodiversity is better than it would have been without the project. That means knowing what was there at the start, what would have happened anyway, and what changed.
A 2024 paper by Aide in npj Biodiversity, The Biodiversity Credit Market needs rigorous baseline, monitoring, and validation practices, argues that biodiversity credits risk repeating two problems seen with carbon credits: inaccurate baselines and weak monitoring. Its remedies start with dynamic baselines that use control sites. It also calls for comprehensive species monitoring, and for credits to be validated independently.

Each of those steps turns into a practical demand on whoever collects the data.
What a credit claims | What the evidence has to show | What field monitoring has to keep |
|---|---|---|
Biodiversity was at level X at the start | A baseline tied to a place and a date | Records with their original date and location, kept unchanged |
The gain would not have happened anyway | Comparison with similar sites outside the project | The same survey method used at project and control sites |
Biodiversity has improved since the start | Repeat measurement over years | Surveys repeated on a schedule, with no records quietly removed |
The numbers are real | Independent validation | Raw records a verifier can open and trace, not just a summary |
None of this is new to ecologists. What is new is the scale. If credits grow the way their backers hope, a lot of projects in remote places will need repeat surveys for years. Short visits by outside specialists are expensive, and that cost is part of why monitoring ends up thin. People who live in a project area are there all year.
Where community-led monitoring fits, and where it stops
This is the gap CitizenClimate is built for: community members collect the field records, and the platform keeps them in a form a verifier can check. Here is what the app does today, as described in our VVB Protocol and App Guide.
Records that keep their history. Every submission is timestamped. Records collected offline keep the time and place they were recorded, and the sync date is stored separately. Location can be required or optional for each survey; where it is required, the survey will not start without a GPS fix. Submissions can never be deleted. A faulty record is archived with a reason from a fixed list, so the trail stays visible.

Species identification with the evidence attached. Plants, birds (by call), insects, mushrooms, animals and crop health can be identified by third-party AI services. Each result carries the scientific and common name with a confidence score, plus the species' IUCN status, and it is stored exactly as returned. Photos and recordings taken offline are identified when the phone reconnects. The platform does not treat AI output as ground truth, and an ecologist can inspect and override any identification.
A baseline for PV Nature projects. Plan Vivo's PV Nature standard quantifies biodiversity as change over time: Plan Vivo says "Percentage change in the multimetric per hectare per year forms the unit change that underpins the quantification methodology." When a project developer enrols a project in our PV Nature module, they choose the ecosystem and certificate type, then set a baseline year and pick target groups. Field records feed pillar metrics 1 to 3. Pillars 4 and 5 use satellite imagery inside the site boundary. A multimetric shows combined change since the baseline. The PV Nature walkthrough shows how this works with a fictional demo project.

Calculations a verifier can re-run. For PV Nature metrics, the platform produces an audit bundle: "a .zip with the data, code and results, so an auditor can re-run the calculation". VVBs get a read-only role with direct access to project data, and data exports in CSV and JSON include raw records, not just summaries.
A voice for the people on the land. The objections raised at COP17 were partly about who benefits and who is heard. The app's grievance mechanism lets members file a grievance anonymously; grievances cannot be deleted, and VVBs can read all of them.
Where it stops matters just as much:
We do not issue credits or calculate official PV Nature metrics. Under PV Nature, an approved Data Analytic Provider calculates the official pillar metrics and multimetric; CitizenClimate's job is to deliver clean, structured, auditable data. CitizenClimate is not affiliated with the Plan Vivo Foundation (see our Plan Vivo alignment page).
The platform does not set the sampling design. It records what is submitted, not how the survey was structured. Control sites and plot layout belong in the project design document.
The general biodiversity dashboard is cumulative. It does not yet show time series. Time-series dashboards are on the development roadmap. Until then, records are stored in full with their timestamps, so change over time can be analysed from the CSV export.
CitizenClimate's data is structured to align with the monitoring requirements of Verra VCS, Gold Standard, Plan Vivo, Puro.earth and Carbon Standards International. CitizenClimate is not certified, accredited or endorsed by any standard body, and it does not issue credits. Whether a project's evidence shows additionality is for the standard and the verifier to judge.
The walkthrough above follows a fictional demo project from set-up to live data; the project and its figures are illustrative.
What project teams can do before the study lands
Carbon Brief reports that the study behind the COP17 biodiversity credits debate is subject to available financial resources. In our view, its findings may take some time to shape market rules. Projects selling or planning biodiversity credits do not need to wait for it. Buyers will ask the additionality question anyway, and so will verifiers.
Fix the baseline now. Record species and habitat condition before activities start, at known places, with dated records you will never overwrite.
Pick control sites and survey them the same way. A gain inside the project means little without a comparison outside it.
Write the sampling protocol down. Plot size and transect length belong in the project design document, as do visit duration and season, so repeat surveys can be compared.
Plan for years of repeat visits. Budget for who will do them. Monitors who live locally, with rewards the project sets, may be able to visit more often than occasional outside teams.
Keep raw records open to the verifier. Summaries are useful, but a verifier needs to trace any figure back to the observations behind it.
Give the community a channel. A grievance record that cannot be deleted is evidence of process, and the COP17 objections show that process is now part of integrity.
For the case that local knowledge belongs at the centre of nature markets, see our earlier post on why community knowledge matters for biodiversity credits.
Frequently asked questions
Did COP17 ban or approve biodiversity credits?
Neither. Biodiversity credits and offsets remain an accepted means of mobilising finance under target 19 of the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework. The resource mobilisation decision added a request for a study on whether credits and offsets generate additionality in biodiversity conservation. Carbon Brief reports that the study is subject to available financial resources, and no market rules were changed in Yerevan.
What is the Friends of Credits for Nature and Biodiversity?
It is an informal, government-led initiative launched by the European Commission at COP17 on 27 October 2026, at an event co-hosted with France and Peru. The Commission says twelve further countries, five of them EU member states, were welcomed to the initiative. It aims to build international support for nature credits. Its next steps include a side-event at COP31 on 18 November.
What does additionality mean for a biodiversity credit?
Additionality means the biodiversity gain would not have happened without the project. To show it, a project needs a dated baseline, a comparison with similar sites outside the project, repeat measurements using the same method over time, and records an independent verifier can check. Without those, a credit may pay for change that was happening anyway, or for no change at all.
Can community members collect data for biodiversity credits?
They can collect field records, and in many remote project areas they are the only people present all year. The data still needs a written sampling protocol and consistent methods. Each record also has to keep its original timestamp and location along with its evidence. Standards and verifiers decide whether the evidence is enough. Under PV Nature, official metrics are calculated by an approved Data Analytic Provider.
The short version
The COP17 biodiversity credits outcome left the instrument in place and asked a fair question about it. The answer will come from projects that can show a baseline and a comparison, backed by years of traceable records from people who are actually on the land. If you are planning that kind of monitoring, download the free app and try the demo project to see how surveys and exports work, including the PV Nature module.



Comments