top of page
Search
Blog cover: every kiln run needs its proof, beside an illustration of a farmer weighing biomass on a scale

Open-kiln biochar methodology: what Rainbow's dMRV rules ask for

Writer: Nick
Nick
11 minutes ago
9 min read

Rainbow's open-kiln biochar methodology, published as Distributed open-kiln biochar v1.0 on 24 April 2026, credits carbon removal from biochar made in cone-shaped, flame-curtain kilns run by many small operators. It makes a third-party digital MRV (dMRV) platform a hard requirement. If any required proof is missing from that platform, the whole kiln run is ineligible. On 13 November 2026 a community-led project in western India using the methodology announced an A.pre ex ante rating from BeZero Carbon, so these rules now have a live test case.


This post sets out what happened, what the methodology asks each role in a kiln network to record, and where a community field app fits.


What happened: Agnisparsh and its A.pre rating

According to the press release published on 13 November 2026, Varaha's project Agnisparsh (registry ID RIV2026PROJ164) has been assigned a BeZero Carbon ex ante rating of A.pre, with low project execution risk, as of October 2026. The project is in western India. It will turn agricultural residues from smallholder farmers into biochar in about 450 Kon-Tiki kilns across multiple mobile sites at full operation. Varaha plans its first credit issuance for January 2027 and expects more than 100,000 t of removals in 2027.


CarbonCredits.com's report of 16 November 2026 confirms the same figures. It also notes that an ex ante rating does not guarantee future issuance or actual removal.


What does A.pre mean? On BeZero's rating scale, ratings run on eight points from AAA to D, and "A" means a "high likelihood of achieving 1 tonne of CO₂e avoidance or removal". The ".pre" marks a rating given before any credits are issued. In the release, BeZero's chief executive Tommy Ricketts describes it as "our independent opinion on the likelihood of a pre-issuance carbon credit".


There is a standards angle too. On 5 March 2026 the ICVCM confirmed Rainbow as CCP-Eligible, for Standard Rules v7 or later only. That covers the programme, not each methodology. Only credits issued under CCP-Approved methodologies can carry the CCP label, and both news reports say the open-kiln methodology is still under assessment.


Rainbow's chief executive, Ludovic Chatoux, is quoted in the release on the methodology "including mandatory digital MRV". That phrase is the reason this matters to anyone who collects field data.


The open-kiln biochar methodology in brief

The methodology's main page lists it as RBW-BCR-DOB-V1.0, released on 24 April 2026, with the status "In use". Rainbow publishes a separate methodology for closed kilns. The open-kiln version has its own rules on kiln design and photo proof, and it allows only the carbon mass balance method for methane.


The eligibility and scope page sets the main conditions:


  • Kilns. Only open kilns with a conical flame-curtain design are eligible. Steel Kon-Tiki cones and steel-shielded soil pits qualify; unmodified soil pits do not. Pyrolysis must stay at 350°C or higher for the full duration, excluding ramp-up.

  • Kiln identity. Each kiln needs fixed, continuously logging thermocouples in the same position on every kiln, and a permanent unique identifier, such as a QR code or engraved serial number.

  • Feedstock. Forest waste, agro-food waste and invasive species, each with its own proof and leakage rules. Each production batch uses one feedstock type or a consistent mix.

  • End use. Credits depend on end use: direct soil application, soil products such as compost where biochar is under 50% by volume, or concrete and asphalt. Biochar must have a molar H/Corg below 0.7.

  • Production batch. A batch is valid for a maximum of 6 months or 200 tonnes of biochar, whichever comes first.


Four roles carry the evidence. Kiln operators run the kilns and record the raw data. Kiln supervisors are hired by the project developer to check quality on the ground. The project developer checks every kiln run. The VVB checks a sample of the raw records.


What the dMRV platform must record for every kiln run

The principles and requirements page lists what the chosen dMRV platform must track. It must also give kiln operators step-by-step procedures. The table follows that list in the order a kiln run happens.


Step

What the dMRV platform must hold

The kiln

Scanned QR code of the kiln, and photos of its required technical features

Biomass moisture

Photos of moisture meter readings. The sampling and measurements page asks for one reading per 100 kg of dried feedstock, with at least 10 per run. The mean must be below 20% for woody biomass or 15% for other biomass, and no reading may exceed 25%

Biomass amount

Photos of the biomass before each run, plus its mass or volume

Pyrolysis

Continuous thermocouple readings, and photos through the run, including at least one after the last biomass addition showing an "intact and clean flame curtain"

Quenching

Time-stamped photos or short videos showing when quenching started and ended

Biochar produced

Volume plus the supervisor's bulk density, or mass plus moisture content

Sampling

Scanned QR codes of the original biochar bags, and photos of the sample

Delivery and application

Scanned QR codes of delivery bags and photos, with the date, GPS coordinates, address, amount, user or buyer and production batch ID

Diagram of the evidence trail for one open-kiln biochar run, from kiln QR code to application
Our summary of Rainbow's Distributed open-kiln biochar v1.0 requirements. Check every step against the methodology text.

Rules on the record itself

The same page sets rules for the records, not only their content:


  • All photographs must have a timestamp and GPS coordinates. All temperature curves must have a timestamp.

  • Delayed uploads must show the upload time and go up as a full batch when there is signal, not as hand-picked files.

  • The platform must stop kiln operators from changing data once it is uploaded.

  • Rainbow, the project developer and the VVB need an oversight-only view and exportable files.

  • Records must be kept for at least five years after the final monitoring period.


Then comes the line that decides credits: using an approved platform is not enough on its own, and if any operational proof is missing, "the entire kiln run is ineligible".


Kiln supervisors and the 20% check

Volume is easy to record in the field. Mass is what gets credited. The methodology bridges the two with a dry bulk density measured by the kiln supervisor, at least once per site per year or when feedstock changes. The sampling and measurements page asks for standard containers and calibrated scales. Oven drying must run at 110°C or more for at least 48 hours, unless a laboratory-grade moisture analyser is used. The batch value is the mean minus one standard deviation of all measurements, which leans conservative.


The supervisor visits each kiln operator at least once a year, watches one kiln run, collects the site composite sample and submits proof of the visit. Supervisors must not receive payments or incentives tied to the number of credits issued (eligibility and scope).

Stat card: 20%, the minimum share of events whose raw dMRV records the VVB must check
Source: Rainbow, Distributed open-kiln biochar v1.0, principles and requirements.

Verification goes back to the raw records. The VVB checks the complete records for a random sample covering "at least 20% of all events", plus every supervisor bulk density and moisture record. If thermocouples fail, biochar from those runs can be credited only if the failure is explained, failures are not consecutive, and the affected runs make up no more than 5% of the batch's biochar.


What changes for the people who keep the records

For project developers, the unit of risk is the kiln run. A missing quench photo or an unscanned bag can cost a whole run, so the field process has to make the complete record the easy path. The developer also checks every run for consistency: run duration against biochar produced, the feedstock pile against biochar output, and biochar produced against biochar reported in an eligible end use.


For VVBs, the methodology moves the check from summaries to raw records. A verifier needs read access to individual runs with their photos and timestamps attached, and enough runs to cover the 20% sample.


For kiln operators, the workload is real: at least 10 moisture readings per run, photos at each stage, a quench video or timed photos, and sampling after every run. Training is required, and the methodology lists dMRV use among the topics. The eligibility page says operators receive carbon finance distributed by the supervisor or developer, so how a record is made also affects how people are paid.


Our reading, not a Rainbow rule: the evidence for a distributed project is created by many people, often without signal, days before anyone at the developer sees it. A record that keeps when and where it was made, and that nobody can quietly edit, does most of the work.


Where community-led dMRV fits, and the gaps

We have not assessed CitizenClimate against Rainbow's methodology. CitizenClimate is not approved, listed or endorsed by Rainbow, and it has no connection to Varaha, BeZero or the Agnisparsh project. CitizenClimate's data is structured to align with the monitoring requirements of Verra VCS, Gold Standard, Plan Vivo, Puro.earth and Carbon Standards International. CitizenClimate is not certified, accredited or endorsed by any standard body, and it does not issue credits.


What follows compares Rainbow's record rules with what our App Guide and the Data Integrity and Methodology Protocol describe today, gaps included.


Rainbow asks for

What the App Guide and Protocol describe

Step-by-step procedures for operators

Surveys answered question by question; some questions only appear after certain answers. Lessons with text, images and video, many ending with a short quiz

Photos and short videos at each step

Photo and video question types, with image quality set per field

Timestamp and GPS on every photo

Every submission is timestamped, and each media file stores its upload time. GPS is stored with the submission when the survey records a location, not separately on each photo. Photos can also be chosen from the gallery. Agree with your VVB whether that is enough

Delayed uploads show the upload time

Offline records keep their original timestamp; the sync date is recorded separately

Operators cannot change uploaded data

Submissions, photos and videos can never be deleted. Coordinates "cannot be modified after submission". A project developer can only archive a record with a reason

Oversight-only view and exports

A read-only VVB role, and CSV and JSON exports of raw records. No separate role for a standard body is described

QR codes on kilns and bags

Not described. There is no QR scan question type; a kiln ID can be typed or picked from a list, which is weaker evidence

Continuous thermocouple readings

Not described in the App Guide or the Protocol

Five-year record retention

No retention period is stated

Supervisor bulk density and moisture uploads

No supervisor role; a separate survey with number and photo questions could be set up for supervisors


The App Guide and the Protocol also describe a daily check that reviews new submissions with photos, recordings or written answers. Clearly faulty ones, including media reused from another submission, are archived with a reason beginning "AI verification:". Anything uncertain is left for a person to check. That is a screening step, not a substitute for the developer's run-by-run review.

CitizenClimate app feedstock survey question rating moisture from very dry to very wet
A real feedstock survey question in the CitizenClimate app. A rating scale like this would not meet Rainbow's rule; a number question plus a photo of each meter reading would be needed.

For plant-scale producers, our biochar MRV page explains that the platform is designed to take reactor, weighbridge and lab (LIMS) data by REST API, so batch records arrive without retyping. Get in touch to talk through the systems you use. Kiln thermocouple loggers are not named there. On rewards, projects can attach points and an optional currency reward to each survey. Under the Protocol, rewards for a submission are reversed if the daily check rejects it. How operators are paid stays with the project.


The walkthrough film below follows Serra Clara Biochar, a fictional project with illustrative figures. It is not a Rainbow project.

Illustration of a farmer spreading biochar on pasture while another person photographs the treated strip
Illustration: AI-generated image of biochar application, not a real project.

For how other standards treat small kilns, see our posts on Gold Standard's PARC methodology and the Global Artisan C-Sink roles and documents.


Frequently asked questions

What is Rainbow's open-kiln biochar methodology?

It is Distributed open-kiln biochar v1.0 (RBW-BCR-DOB-V1.0), released by Rainbow on 24 April 2026. It credits carbon removal from biochar made in conical flame-curtain kilns, such as steel Kon-Tiki cones, run by many small operators. It requires a third-party dMRV platform, and a kiln run with missing proof is ineligible.


What does an A.pre rating from BeZero mean?

It is an ex ante rating, given before a project issues credits. BeZero's scale runs from AAA to D, and A means a high likelihood that a credit achieves one tonne of CO₂e avoidance or removal. Agnisparsh's A.pre came with low project execution risk, as of October 2026. It does not guarantee future issuance.


Is the open-kiln methodology CCP-approved?

Not as far as the reports show. The ICVCM confirmed Rainbow as a CCP-Eligible programme on 5 March 2026, for Standard Rules v7 or later. Each methodology is assessed separately, and news reports from November 2026 say the open-kiln methodology is still under assessment. Only credits from CCP-Approved methodologies can carry the CCP label.


How is biochar measured in an open-kiln project?

Either by volume or by mass. With volume, operators fill standard containers after each run and the supervisor measures dry bulk density at least once per site per year. The batch value is the mean minus one standard deviation. With mass, all output is weighed, and if it is weighed after quenching, moisture is measured on at least 3 samples per production batch.


Plan the record before the first burn

Rainbow's open-kiln biochar methodology turns each kiln run into its own unit of evidence, and a verifier will open the raw records. Before you light a kiln, map every required photo and reading to a screen in your field app, and close or work around the gaps with your VVB. To see how timestamped offline records and an archive-with-reason audit trail work in practice, download the free app or read the App Guide.

Comments


bottom of page